from: http://www.undressmerobot.com
Lost Girls labors under 15 years of anticipation, work, and the legendary cantankerous, brilliant reputation of its writer: Alan Moore. Moore’s artist (and now, wife) Melinda Gebbie is no stranger to dispute herself, having been confronted with burnings of her books and plenty of heated discussion. The combination of these two minds is enough to cause a buzz—notwithstanding that, when asked, Moore will classify this graphic novel as pornography without the benefit of quotation marks trapping the word or excuses and apologies. One might suppose that expectation alone would overshadow this release and that no matter how good or shocking or thought-provoking it turned out, the controversy would fizzle or the narrative would disappoint. Neither of these outcomes comes to fruition after reading Book One: “Older Children.”
Initially, I was going to take on reviewing all three books at the same time. After finishing Book One, I realized that this wouldn’t be possible. My two pages of notes on this first installment couldn’t be shoved into one terse statement. Also, the text raises so many questions and ripe situations for debate that it deserves more than just a surface treatment. There hasn’t been anything like this before in comics and so therefore I feel a bit as if each step I take crunches eggshells. That said, I’m not going to shy away from spoilers, so if you don’t want to know specific plot points, you need to stop reading this.
As simply put as possible, the story concerns three main characters that most people will recognize from their childhood: Dorothy Gale, Alice Fairchild, and Wendy Darling. These names are familiar from the stories read to children as The Wizard of Oz, Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland, and Peter Pan. All grown up now, each woman is a slave to her past, as they will come to find out. “Older Children” takes us through the process of these women encountering each other in the Hotel Himmelgarten, a Swiss hotel with unique white volumes in the place normally occupied by Bibles in guestrooms. With the backdrop of the hotel and the book in each room, the women begin an exploration that will inevitably draw in everyone around them and forever change their view of the world.
It is fitting that Moore has separated this epic into three books, and the three books into respective chapters. The rigid structure makes it easier to keep track of the action and it suits the story better, which is really more of a novel than a lot of the books on the bestseller lists. If you take a peek at the price for this lushly manufactured set, you may be a bit shocked. You’d be even more stunned searching for the individual books on any Internet auction site.
In Chapter 1 (“The Mirror”), we meet Lady Fairchild, an older woman with a penchant for erotica and mind-altering substances. She comes from a privileged family, and therefore can get away with being a bit batty; this makes her a perfect tour-guide for our introduction into the bizarre world of Lost Girls. (Lady Fairchild, better known as Alice, has much experience traversing unknown territory.) Rendered in soft lines and extremely realistic features, the readers only view Fairchild through her precious mirror for the first part of the story. Gebbie’s art immediately casts a spell, taking you out of the ordinary world. Each panel could be a painting, with the amount of detail and obvious love she has given them. If you’re looking for exaggerated and improbable comic babes, you won’t find them here. The mirror’s gilt frame serves as a border for the panels and exemplifies well the captive feelings Fairchild hides.
As soon as the first chapter opens, we see Fairchild masturbating with abandon and seemingly talking to the mirror while she pleasures herself. She seeks the mirror’s approval constantly, and when she encounters a fan of her fiction upon arriving at the Himmelgarten, she summarizes Plato in reply: “…the world beyond fiction’s mirror, that is the true world and we are but the faintest reflections grown pale beneath the glass.” This weighty statement, as we will later see, elucidates much about how her checkered childhood has affected her.
Chapter 2, “Silver Shoes,” introduces us to Miss Gale (or “Dottie,” until we find out exactly who she is). Once again, the art is totally striking and so different from anything comic readers are used to seeing. Miss Gale immediately starts her sexual adventures as well, meeting a dashing young man named Rolf Bauer who is at the Himmelgarten to “convalesce.” (Let me interject here that one of the many reasons I love Alan Moore is that he doesn’t shy away from so-called “50-cent” words in his comics.) She and Rolf copulate with abandon outside the hotel, and this first sex scene initiates us into the uninhibited way intercourse is dealt with in Lost Girls: there will be no demure cutting away from explicit panels.
In keeping with the theme of the fetish objects of the main characters, we see lots of shots of Dottie’s shoes: silver, striking, and a nod to her red slippers. Rolf likes them, too, a lot. “Like shoes, we try on our fantasies, yes?” he flirts coyly. Miss Gale reminds him that we also outgrow shoes or they become too “dull, familiar, and comfortable.” Dorothy’s over-the-top Southern accent is a little distracting at first, but it seems to be meant to demonstrate her free-spirited, All-American-girl personality.
We’re introduced to the final lady in Chapter 3, “Missing Shadows.” This portion starts with an outstanding page of the balcony, where we can see Lady Fairchild and Dorothy begin their friendship in a series of snaking word balloons that ultimately lead to the stodgy couple who has just occupied the room next to them. Mr. and Mrs. Potter (our Wendy Darling’s new surname) are a middle-aged pair who have become complacent and, of course, sexually unadventurous. This chapter also lets us into the pages of the White Book, the erotica in place of the Bible in their rooms. Gebbie’s mimic of English illustrator Aubrey Beardsley’s work is insanely stunning; in fact, all of the White Book is luxuriously illustrated in the styles of revered erotica, and all of the imitations are spot-on.
In one of the many clever visuals of this installment, the Potters engage in a bit of innuendo-soaked chit-chat while their shadows do all the things that they cannot allow themselves to do.
Chapters 4-6 see the women slowly drawing closer. In the case of Fairchild and Dottie…extremely close. They do not hesitate to get into each other’s knickers, and have no hang-ups or repression. The Potters spy the women in the hotel’s restaurant and their interest is piqued. Mrs. Potter, in particular, can’t seem to stop looking at them and thinking about them. In fact, she’s so intrigued that she’s caught spying on one of their sexual escapades. This incident begins the heart of the book: the three women exploring each other, their mental landscapes, experiences, and the roots of their libidos.
In the next few vignettes, we are treated to individual examinations of the women’s pasts with re-imaginings of our cherished childhood stories. “Re-imagining” is a pretty tame word to use in this context. Dorothy tells her tale first: As a young woman caught in a tornado, thinking that the end is near, she experiences her first orgasm by stimulating herself as the house spins. Gebbie renders Kansas in fittingly rich, sepia tones.
Wendy is goaded into revealing her story next, something that she has not told anyone but has been dying to let out. The art shows the familiar Darling family and Peter Pan in panels that almost look like stained glass. Up until Wendy’s story, nothing in the text had made me uncomfortable, and I was beginning to wonder what the ruckus was about. Instead of trying to describe Mrs. Potter’s experience, I’ll leave the interpretation up to the individual reader. I will say that I’m sure Moore and Gebbie weren’t surprised at the protest of Barrie’s estate.
Lady Fairchild’s memory is not a pleasant one, but it is rife with clever allusions to the Alice of lore. She is approached by Bunny, her father’s oldest friend, who plies her with wine that makes her body feel “too large or too small.” In the same mirror that she is so attached to, we see her molestation. It’s all very vague. Or, at least, it seems that way: the whole sequence is somehow less visceral than the other women’s experiences.
The last chapter in Book One, “Stravinsky,” gives us a bit of historical perspective as Lady Fairchild takes her fellow adventuresses and their men to the opera. In an excerpt from her diary, we see her exasperation with the men and the music enticing the women into a fondling session that no one seems to notice (which is really quite remarkable). Flowing writing and more alluring artwork make it an enjoyable topper. Book One ends on this note, and a promising beginning it is indeed.